Can Billionaires Pay for It?
Updated: Nov 4
So far we saw that capitalism has fine print, and that Denmark and Sweden are far smaller than the US. Now we test the biggest promise: that billionaires can pay for it all.
The Billionaire Math
Ready? In March 2026, Forbes (a business magazine) counted 989 billionaires in the US. Together, they're worth about $8.4 trillion [18]. Split evenly, that's about $8.5 billion each.
(Averages hide a lot. A few fortunes are huge and many are much smaller. It's just the fairest way to split one big total.)
Quick scale check, because these numbers are hard to picture. A trillion is a thousand billions. Just for scale, in plain math: a billion seconds is about 32 years. A trillion seconds is almost 32,000 years. Yep.
That's the size of the numbers we're playing with.


Now the bill. The federal government spent almost $7.4 trillion in the budget year that ended September 30, 2026, according to the US Treasury [19]. (The Treasury is the part of the government that handles its money. The government's budget year runs October to September. It's called a fiscal year.)
Where does it go? The Congressional Budget Office does the math for Congress. It says five big things take about three quarters of it:
Social Security (monthly checks for retirees)
Medicare (health insurance for older people)
Medicaid (health insurance for people with low incomes)
The Military
Interest on the National Debt [36]. Interest is what the government pays for its borrowing.
Now a thought experiment. Say the government grabbed every dollar of those fortunes and sold it all at full listed price. That's not realistic. Forbes "net worth" is not cash. It's an estimate of what everything a person owns is worth. And prices would move if everything got sold at once.
But even in that best case, $8.4 trillion would run the federal government for about a year and two months. Once. Then it's gone, and next year's bill shows up anyway.
In billionaire terms, one year of today's government takes about 870 average billionaires. That's almost 9 out of every 10 of the 989 who exist. And that's BEFORE adding anything new.
Now add something new: healthcare for every American, in year one.
Nobody knows the exact cost, because it depends on how the plan is built. So I looked at what researchers found. I focused on one question: how much NEW spending would the federal government take on in the first year?
This kind of plan is called "single-payer." That means one payer, the government, pays the health bills.
Each study used its own year and its own assumptions, so they don't line up perfectly. Here's what I found:
RAND (a nonprofit research group, 2019): federal health spending would jump from about $1.1 trillion to about $3.5 trillion. That's about $2.4 trillion more [37].
Mercatus Center (a university-based research center that the Associated Press calls libertarian, which means it favors a smaller government, 2018): about $2.5 trillion more in 2022, the first year it looked at. Its author says the real cost would likely be higher. That's because it assumes big cuts to what doctors and hospitals get paid [38][43]. Sen. Bernie Sanders called the study "grossly misleading and biased" [43].
Urban Institute (a research nonprofit; the Commonwealth Fund paid for this study; 2019): about $2.8 trillion more in 2020 for a bigger "enhanced" plan. It has extra benefits and covers everyone, including undocumented immigrants. A smaller "lite" plan covers only legal residents, with some cost sharing and fewer benefits. It adds about $1.5 trillion [39].
American Action Forum (a policy group usually described as leaning conservative, 2026): about $2.5 trillion more in 2027, the first year in its model. About $4.1 trillion more in 2028, the first full year. It leaves out dental, vision and hearing, so it calls its numbers a minimum [40].
So what's the one number? Across five sources (RAND, Mercatus, Urban Institute, the American Action Forum and the Congressional Budget Office), the first-year estimates of NEW federal spending run from $1.5 trillion to $2.8 trillion.
The lowest is Urban's "lite" plan. The highest is Urban's "enhanced" plan. So the estimates differ by $1.3 trillion.
I'm using $2.15 trillion. That's the dead-center midpoint between the lowest and highest estimate. To be clear about what that means: it's the middle of the range. It's not the average of every study. And it's not a claim that this is the most likely number.
It's an estimate, not a bill.
One estimate also sits above the range. The American Action Forum's first full year (2028) is $4.1 trillion. So the midpoint doesn't cover every estimate. (The Congressional Budget Office looked at 2030 instead of a first year. Its range of $1.5 trillion to $3.0 trillion is in the same ballpark [41].)
Why do the estimates differ? A few choices matter:
How much doctors and hospitals get paid. Mercatus assumes pay more than 40 percent below what private insurance pays today. RAND assumes pay a bit above what Medicare pays today.
Whether the plan includes dental, vision, hearing and long-term care. Long-term care is help for people who can't fully care for themselves, like nursing homes.
Whether undocumented immigrants are covered.
How much of today's private and state spending moves onto the federal books.
Here's the part people mix up. That $2.15 trillion is new FEDERAL spending. It is not what the country spends on healthcare overall.
Americans already spent about $5.3 trillion on healthcare in 2024. The federal government already paid 31 percent of that [20].
Under single-payer, a lot of what you pay today in premiums and deductibles would turn into taxes instead. (A premium is your monthly insurance bill. A deductible is what you pay before insurance kicks in.)
The same goes for what your employer pays. So the federal number jumps, while the national number may barely move.
RAND estimated total national health spending would rise just 1.8 percent [37]. A Yale School of Public Health study says it would fall by about $1 trillion a year. Or by at least about $660 billion, if you use more cautious guesses [42]. That study hasn't been reviewed by other scientists yet. That's what "preprint" means.
The American Action Forum disagrees with the Yale estimate. It says lower prices paid to doctors and hospitals are not necessarily the same as lower real costs [40].
Bottom line: the federal bill gets much bigger. Whether the country's total bill gets bigger or smaller is still being argued.
Now let's stack it on the bill. Here it is step by step, so you can show your work to anyone who asks:

Step 1, the average billionaire: about $8.5 billion each. That's $8.4 trillion split 989 ways.
Step 2, one year of today's government: about 870 billionaires. On the year before, it's about 825.
Step 3, add healthcare for everyone, year one: about 250 more billionaires. That's the $2.15 trillion midpoint.
Step 4, the total: about 1,120 average billionaires. On the year before, it's about 1,080.
Step 5, compare that to who exists: about 130 MORE billionaires than the US actually has. On the year before, it's about 90 more.
Step 6, the money gap: year one needs about $9.5 trillion. We have $8.4 trillion in this best case. That's about $1.1 trillion short.
So, the math officially ain't mathin'. Even in a total fantasy world where we strip every single American billionaire down to their very last cent, we still crash into a trillion-dollar brick wall on day one.
The "eat the rich" strategy sounds clean on a protest sign, but it doesn't even survive the first year's health bill.
If the ultra-wealthy can't buy us paradise, it leaves us staring down the barrel of two massive, uncomfortable questions: Who is actually going to have to swipe their card for this? And what happens to the global safety shield we all take for granted if the money runs dry?
Let's turn the page. It's time to read the rest of the fine print in Part 4: Who Pays, Who Protects, and What the Supporters Say.
Sources
18. Forbes, "The Countries With The Most Billionaires 2026," March 11, 2026 (net worths as of March 1, 2026): https://www.forbes.com/sites/samellefson/2026/03/11/the-countries-with-the-most-billionaires/
19. US Treasury, Monthly Treasury Statement, Table 5, September 2026 data (total outlays of $7.396 trillion in fiscal year 2026 and $7.010 trillion in fiscal year 2025): https://api.fiscaldata.treasury.gov/services/api/fiscal_service/v1/accounting/mts/mts_table_5 (dataset page: https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/datasets/monthly-treasury-statement/)
20. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, "NHE Fact Sheet" (2024 data, page modified June 24, 2026): https://www.cms.gov/data-research/statistics-trends-and-reports/national-health-expenditure-data/nhe-fact-sheet
36. Congressional Budget Office, "Monthly Budget Review: September 2026," October 8, 2026 (preliminary fiscal year 2026 outlays by program): https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61985
37. RAND, Liu and Eibner, "National Health Spending Estimates Under Medicare for All," April 10, 2019: https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR3106.html
38. Mercatus Center, Charles Blahous, "The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System," July 30, 2018 (summary page and working paper): https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system and https://www.mercatus.org/system/files/blahous-costs-medicare-mercatus-working-paper-v1_1.pdf
39. Urban Institute, Blumberg, Holahan and others, "From Incremental to Comprehensive Health Reform: How Various Reform Options Compare on Coverage and Costs," October 16, 2019: https://www.urban.org/research/publication/incremental-comprehensive-health-reform-how-various-reform-options-compare-coverage-and-costs
40. American Action Forum, Stephen Parente, "Medicare for All: An Updated Coverage and Budget Analysis," August 24, 2026: https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/medicare-for-all-an-updated-coverage-and-budget-analysis/
41. Congressional Budget Office, "How CBO Analyzes the Costs of Proposals for Single-Payer Health Care Systems That Are Based on Medicare's Fee-for-Service Program" (Working Paper 2020-08), December 10, 2020: https://www.cbo.gov/publication/56811
42. Yale School of Public Health, "Universal Health Coverage Could Save $1 Trillion and 114,000 Lives Every Year, Yale Study Projects," August 13, 2026 (preprint, not yet peer reviewed): https://ysph.yale.edu/news-article/universal-health-coverage-could-save-one-trillion-dollars-and-114000-lives-every-year/
43. Associated Press via WHYY, "Libertarian policy center study: 'Medicare for all' projected to cost $32.6 trillion," July 30, 2018: https://whyy.org/articles/libertarian-policy-center-study-medicare-for-all-projected-to-cost-32-6-trillion/




Comments