Who Pays, Who Protects and What the Supporters Say
Updated: Nov 4
We just did the math. Even if the government took every listed dollar from every US billionaire, year one would still come up short. So who pays, and what about defense?
So, who actually pays? Billionaires can't cover it, so the bill spreads to lots more people. Let's use Sweden as an example.
Sweden has a top tax rate of about 52 percent [21][22]. That's the rate on each extra dollar you earn above a certain line. It is not the rate on your whole paycheck.
That line is about $64,000 a year [22]. That's a bit above what the average Swedish worker earns. So if you land a great starter job at around sixty or seventy grand, you'd be right around where Sweden's top tax rate begins.
Denmark's top rate is even higher, at about 57 percent [23].
Both countries also charge a 25 percent sales tax called VAT — baked into the price tag, so you never see the line.

But here's what Americans miss: it isn't just on stuff. Denmark charges 25% on practically everything, goods and services:
the haircut
the plumber's labor
dinner out
your phone bill
Sweden's 25% hits most goods and services too, with a few breaks:
12% at restaurants and hotels
6% on books, bus tickets
(until the end of 2027) groceries. (I know not all US states are like this, but I live in Texas, where groceries aren't taxed at all and most services skip sales tax completely.
And don't forget gasoline. Denmark has the most expensive petrol in the EU — about $10.60 a gallon — and roughly half of that is tax. They charge fuel duties first, then charge 25% VAT on top of the price that already includes the duties. A tax on a tax.
Sweden stacks theirs the same way: energy tax, carbon tax, then 25% VAT on the whole pile. In Texas, you pay 20 cents a gallon in state tax and that's the end of it.
Here's what's missing from this specific beautiful, convenient "we can solve everything" app.
Groceries: 40 out of 50 states charge zero state sales tax on groceries. Five have no sales tax at all (Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, Oregon). Only a handful still tax your cart — Hawaii, Idaho, Mississippi, South Dakota at full rate, plus a few at reduced rates.
Plumber/electrician/HVAC labor: In 32 states, that labor isn't taxed at all. Only 6 states tax it (Hawaii, New Mexico, South Dakota, Washington, Mississippi, Delaware), and only 3 states in the whole country tax services broadly. In Texas, residential repair labor isn't taxed, period. Denmark taxes the plumber's labor at the same 25% as everything else.
Gas tax: Highest is California — about 92¢ a gallon total including federal. Lowest is Alaska — about 27¢. No state has zero gas tax. Even California — the most taxed state in America — charges 92 cents a gallon in gas tax. Denmark charges over five dollars a gallon in tax. Not five dollars for the gas. Five dollars of just tax.


That "free candy" isn't a gift. You're paying for it out of your own paycheck — about 25 cents on nearly every dollar you spend.. And a system this big takes years to build.
Want the exact numbers?
Population: Denmark 6.04 million (September 2026) [14]. Sweden 10.62 million (August 2026) [15]. Florida 23.5 million (2025) [16]. The US 341.8 million (July 2025) [17].
Sweden: a 20 percent national income tax starts above 625,800 kronor in 2025 (643,000 kronor in 2026) [21]. On top of that is a local income tax that averages 32.41 percent. Together that's a top rate of about 52 percent. Average Swedish pay was 557,053 kronor in 2025, so the top rate starts at about 112 percent of average pay. At 9.82 kronor per dollar, that's about $64,000 [22].
Denmark: the combined top rate reaches about 57 percent in 2026. It's 60.5 percent if you count a separate 8 percent labor market charge. The top rate starts at 845,543 kroner [23].

The Global Security Blindspot and the NATO Umbrella
Now the last point for socialism. A popular idea is: just take money from the military to pay for the safety net. But here's the fine print: the Global Security Blindspot. Critics of the Nordic model say Denmark and Sweden can spend so much on their people partly because the US carries so much of the West's protection through NATO. NATO is a team of countries that promised to defend each other.
Let's see what the numbers say.
Think of NATO like a group insurance plan. But the shared plan is tiny. Most of the cost never goes through it. Each country pays for its own military out of its own budget. So there are two different bills. And they give two different answers.
NATO's shared pot. Running NATO itself costs about 4.6 billion euros for 2025. Countries chip in based on the size of their economies [28]. A watchdog group called Taxpayers for Common Sense says the US pays about 16 percent of that shared pot [29]. That's a small slice of what members spend on defense. All 32 NATO members together spent about $1.58 trillion on their militaries in 2025. That's according to SIPRI, a research group in Stockholm that tracks military spending [27].
Military spending. By NATO's own numbers, the US pays about 60 percent of the combined military spending of the US, Europe and Canada in 2025. In 2014, it was about 73 percent [26]. SIPRI agrees. The US spent about $954 billion of that $1.58 trillion, also about 60 percent [27].
So here's the real point. NATO's shared pot is small. Most defense is paid out of each country's own budget. And by that measure, the US carries about 60 percent.
One more fact: Sweden joined NATO in March 2024 [26]. So it has not been under the NATO umbrella for decades.
Now say the US did a total 180 and moved money away from defense in a shaky world. That would leave a security gap.
For scale, the whole US military budget was about $954 billion in 2025 [27]. So even moving all of it would be under $1 trillion a year. "Trillions" would only happen over several years. And other countries won't pause their plans while we spend years rebuilding our economy.
Critics of big military cuts point to two moments in history.
Rome, the 200s AD: Roman emperors kept watering down their coins, using less precious metal in each one, to pay for bigger armies. Chaos followed. Money and daily life got shaky while would-be emperors fought over who would rule [31]. The lesson critics take from it: an army that can't be paid reliably makes a whole empire shaky.
Ukraine, the 1990s: When the Soviet Union broke up, Ukraine had the third-largest stash of nuclear weapons in the world. That was about 1,900 long-range warheads. By 1996, it had sent them all to Russia. In return, it got economic help and promises of safety. That included a 1994 deal called the Budapest Memorandum, signed by the US, Russia and the UK. Ukrainian politicians were split at the time on whether to give them up. Russia took over Crimea in 2014 and launched a full invasion on February 24, 2022 [30]. Paper promises of safety are the fine print of that deal.
Want the exact numbers?
By NATO's figures, the US spent about $845 billion in 2025, and everyone else in the US, Europe and Canada combined spent about $559 billion (in 2021 dollars). In 2014, it was $747 billion versus $279 billion [26].
NATO's shared budget for 2025: about 4.6 billion euros [28]. US share: about 16 percent in 2024 [29].
SIPRI: the US spent $954 billion of $1.58 trillion across all 32 NATO members in 2025 [27].
The Online Shopping Butterfly Effect: Amazon, SHEIN, and TikTok
Think about it simply. A lot of what you order on TikTok, SHEIN and Amazon is made overseas. It reaches you on a giant cargo ship that has to cross open ocean.
The US Navy is a big part of why those ships get across safely.
The US makes up about a third of the world's military spending [27]. But it's not alone. Combined Maritime Forces is a team of 47 countries that patrols some of the world's key shipping lanes. It even has a task force just for fighting pirates [32].
Critics of big military cuts warn that if navies pull back, the sea lanes get riskier. And history even offers a warning.
Many historians say the Golden Age of Piracy ran from about 1650 to 1730. Others use a narrower window, like the 1680s to the 1720s.
Pirates attacked thousands of ships in the Atlantic and beyond. Most of it was around the Caribbean and the east coast of North America [33][34]. Causes included smaller European navies in some places.
Also, sailors and privateers lost their jobs when wars ended [34]. (A privateer was a ship owner licensed by a government to attack enemy ships.) It ended in the 1720s, when navies hunted pirates down and governments offered pardons [33].
And, if you don't believe piracy still exists, ask Captain Phillips what he thinks. I have a feeling he will have a very different opinion.

Now picture that happening again. The cheap phones, sneakers, makeup and gaming gear you love show up slower and cost more.
You might get "free healthcare" on paper. But your rent, gas and daily basics could spike too.
Breaking the shield doesn't buy you paradise. It just crashes the system we all rely on to survive.
The case its supporters make. Supporters of the Nordic model say it pairs a market economy with a strong safety net. Denmark's prime minister said in 2015 that it gives people a high level of security and is also a successful market economy [13].
Supporters also point to the Commonwealth Fund's "Mirror, Mirror 2024" report. It ranked the US last of 10 rich countries overall.
The other nine all cover everybody. The US doesn't [35]. (The same report ranked the US second on how care is delivered, and Sweden did comparatively poorly there. The Commonwealth Fund is a health-policy foundation.)
Supporters also push back on the "free ride" idea, which says Europe lets the US pay for its protection. NATO's 2025 estimates say Denmark spends 3.22 percent of its economy on defense. That's the same share as the US. Sweden spends 2.51 percent [26].
On funding, supporters of single-payer say their plans don't lean on billionaire wealth alone. The money plan tied to the Medicare for All Act has seven pieces, according to the American Action Forum's summary.
A tax on employers
A tax on households
A health care tax
Higher income taxes
A wealth tax
An estate tax (a tax on inherited money)
A tax on S corporations (a type of business) [40].
The American Action Forum says even with all seven, there's still a gap of about $2.4 trillion in 2028. Supporters can also point to the Yale study described above [42].
Step Out of the Noise: Make Your Choice Informed




Comments